Showing posts with label sins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sins. Show all posts

Temporal Punishment for Sin in the New Testament

Question:
Do you know of any New Testament passage that shows that temporal punishment may remain after a sin has been forgiven?
Answer:

Yes, although indirectly. We can say, for example, that Paul's quote of Psalm 51 in Romans 4:7 of David's chastisement even though David was forgiven, is a case in point. If Paul is saying that David's justification is the same justification we have, then it follows that David's chastisement, even though forgiven, also applies to us.

We could also cite 1 Cor 10:1-11 in this regard, since Paul specifically says that we are going to suffer the same things the Jews suffered if we sin. In fact, he says in verses 6 and 11 that those stories were written down precisely to warn us that the same chastisements and final judgments will happen to us.

In fact, we can safely say that any time the NT refers to something that God did to an OT person for his sin, whether it was chastisement after forgiveness or eternal damnation for unrepentance, the same applies to the NT, otherwise, the NT could not use the OT as the example of how God is going to treat us.

There are also general references to ongoing chastisement in Heb 12:6-8; 2 Pet 2:20; Rev 3:19, et al.

Robert Sungenis
Catholic Apologetics International
July 3, 2002

Mortal vs. Venial Sins

Question:
What is the biblical basis between mortal and venial sins?
Answer:
In regards to your question about the forgiveness of sin and the concept of mortal and venial sin, I have listed some verses below with a short explanation.

Confesson of sin to the Church:

Matt 16:18-19; 18:18 - If read literally, obviously Jesus gave Peter and the Church the power to bind and loose, which means they have the power to adjudicate spiritual matters. Peter shows us examples of this in Acts 1 when he chose the twelfth apostle; in Acts 5 when he chose to bind Ananias and Sapphira; in Acts 15 when he decides to loose the practice of circumcision, et al.

John 20:23 - If read literally, obviously, Jesus is giving the apostles the power to forgive sins through His name. Protestants don't like this, so they spiritualize the verse to make it refer to the gospel, but that is not what Jesus said. If he wanted to say that the gospel is what forgives sin, He would have done so. The Catholic Church takes Scripture at face value, for no one has the right to spiritualize a passage without direct authorization from God.

2 Cor 5:18 - If read literally, it is clear that Paul is saying that his and the apostle's ministry involves reconciling people to Christ, which according to the above passage, is getting them to confess their sins to God through the Church.

James 5:14-15 - If read literally, it is clear that the Church is called when someone is sick and near death. The presbyters lay hands on the person, pray to God, and the person's sins are forgiven. That's what the verse says. Protestants don't like this so they either ignore the passage or spiritualize it to refer to the gospel, as they do with John 20:23.

Acts 2:38 - This passage teaches that repentance and Baptism are necessary for the forgiveness of sins. Baptism is administered by the Church. The same truth is taught in Mark 16:16. Protestants don't like giving such power to Baptism, so they make Baptism a secondary issue, but these passages simply won't allow such an interpretation.

Acts 19:18 - This shows that the people confessed their sins to a higher authority, the same as John 20:23 or James 5:14-15.

Mortal and Venial Sin (or degrees of sin)

Matt 12:39-45 - This passage shows the degradation to which sin can lead. Jesus says in verse 45 that "the last state of the man is worse than the first," which means that the man is deeper in his sin presently than he was in the past. This shows degrees of sin and debauchery. The deeper one is in sin the harder it is to come out of it.

Matt 23:14-15 - These passages show that the degree of eternal punishment is based on the degree of the sin. The Pharisees will receive a greater damnation for greater sin. The same principle is in Luke 10:12.

Luke 12:47-48 - This passage teaches that there are degrees of sin, depending on the knowledge someone has. If someone knows what to do but refuses to do it, he has committed a greater sin, and will be punished with a greater punishment.

The same principle is in John 5:14

John 19:11 - Obviously, since Jesus says, "he who delivered me up to you has the greater sin," this verse teaches that there are degrees of sin.

Acts 5:3-5 - Obviously, Ananias and Sapphira committed a horrible sin, and that is why their lives were taken. If they had just committed some minor offense (e.g., if they lied about Sapphira's age) they wouldn't have been killed. This again shows degrees of sin.

1 Cor 3:13-17 - Obviously, although the man of verse 15 is punished for his bad works, but he is still saved. But the man of verse 17 is "destroyed" for his bad works, and he is not saved. The latter sin is mortal, the former is venial.

1 Cor 6:9 - Paul is listing the major sins against the ten commandments. These will keep one from the kingdom of heaven. The same kinds of sin and eternal damnation is listed in Gal 5:19-21 and Eph 5:5. Obviously, these kinds of sin are different than the sin in 1 Cor 3:15 (noted above) in which the man who sinned venially can still be saved by fire.

1 Thess 2:16 - Again, there is a greater punishment for greater sin, since Paul says that "wrath has come upon them to the uttermost."

2 Tim 3:6 - This again shows the degree of sin. The men have a "form of godliness" but are the worst type of sinners underneath. They are like the Pharisees who will receive the greater damnation for greater sin (Matt 23:14-15).

Hebrews 10:26-30 - This shows that willful and deliberate sin removes one from the sacrificial power of Christ. That is mortal sin, the opposite of the person in 1 Cor. 3:15. Hebrews 10:29 says such a person will receive a "much severer punishment" because he has despised the blood of the covenant.

James 3:1 - This passage shows that a person who is in leadership is held to a stricter standard, and he will be judged accordingly if he sins.

1 John 5:16-17 - Obviously, this passage distinguishes between two kinds of sin: (a) that not leading to death, and (b) that leading to death. Death is mortal, and thus the Church calls such sin "mortal sin." If you want to call it something else, fine, but the point remains that there is a distinction between two kinds of sin. The one is so grievous that the people are told not to pray for the person (the assumption is that he has died in this sin).

Numbers 15:27-36 - The concept of degrees of sin and ignorance is not a new idea. It was first taught in the OT. This passage, and others like it in the OT, give a whole list of various levels of sin and culpability.

Deut 22:22 - This passage shows that capital crimes, such as adultery or murder, were serious sins that received the sentence of death. For minor sins, the person was required to pay a fine, which is the same idea in 1 Cor 3:15. In fact, the phrase "suffer loss" in 1 Cor 3:15 is derived from the Greek word for "fine, penalty, punishment."

Deut 29:19-21 - This passage shows that for serious and deliberate rebellion against God, God will no longer be willing to forgive. This is the same principle noted in Hebrews 10:26-29 or Hebrews 6:1-6.

I hope this helps you. May God give you much wisdom.

Robert Sungenis
Catholic Apologetics International
July 16, 2001

Forgiving Sins in John 20:23

Question:
In his book The Gospel According to Rome, James McCarthy writes (p.82):
"...John 20:23 uses a significant verb tense. The Lord did not say, 'If you forgive the sins of any, their sins will be forgiven them.' Neither did he say, 'If you forgive the sins of any, their sins are forgiven them.' What He said was, 'If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them.' 
"Here Jesus uses the Greek perfect tense. 'It implies a process, but views that process as having reached its consummation and existing in a finished state.' This means that the disciples had the authority to declare forgiveness to those whom God had already forgiven." 
Whilst it seems obvious to me that this explanation does violence to the apparent meaning of the passage, I am nevertheless unsure as to how to counter this argument at a grammatical or linguistic level.
Answer:

I will be glad to help you on this question. I have dealt with McCarthy a few times in the past eight years. Despite McCarthy's kind demeanor, he has a deep-rooted hatred for the Catholic Church. I once sent a letter to his home in California, but he sent it back to me, unopened. I've asked him to debate through other people that know him, but he continually refuses. The person who asked him said that after he suggested that the debate take place in McCarthy's church, McCarthy said that he was insulted we would ask for such a thing, and that he would not let his church be contaminated by our presence there. So now you know what you are up against. McCarthy touts himself as an expert in Catholic areas, but more than often he makes erroneous assertions and conclusions. I interact with him in about half a dozen times in my new book, Not By Bread Alone. He is constantly making assertions about Greek and Hebrew grammar that simply are not true.

It is apparent from his linguistic analysis that McCarthy is not a Greek or Hebrew scholar. As far as I know, he has had no formal training in either language. All he does is parrot Greek and Hebrew grammar books that he then twists to side with his presuppositions. Most of the time, his references do not really apply to the question at hand, and he often misinterprets the author of the Greek grammar. John 20:23 is a case in point.

I'll use the NASB: "If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them, if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained."

First, just using common sense, if McCarthy's claims are true, then there wouldn't be any reason for Jesus to tell the apostles "If you forgive the sins of any," since under McCarthy's scenario the apostle's forgiveness of sins would not be necessary, because the sins were already forgiven by God. Since sins can't be forgiven twice, and since no man could usurp or trump God, then if God has already forgiven the sins, it is a moot point as to whether or not the apostles forgive the sins.

Second, the words "have been forgiven them" comes from the Greek ‘apheoontai’. This is a verb in the indicative mood, perfect tense, passive voice. Here is McCarthy's explanation of the perfect tense:

"Here Jesus uses the Greek perfect tense. 'It implies a process, but views that process as having reached its consummation and existing in a finished state.' This means that the disciples had the authority to declare forgiveness to those whom God had already forgiven."

We'll attack this in two ways: one is in regard to the other NT usages of the perfect passive ‘apheoontai’; the other is an examination of the Greek perfect tense in general.

The Perfect tense in Greek is used for a variety of things. It is not confined to what McCarthy has described above. Moreover, in many instances, the Perfect tense of Greek cannot be adequately translated into English, since English does not have an interval of time between the act itself and the time when the act is spoken about; nor can English properly express the idea of existing result which the Greek perfect conveys.

The nuances of the Greek perfect tense can be seen in the other usages of apheoontai. This perfect tense verb (in the indicative mood, passive voice) is used 6 times in the NT. The first is Luke 5:20, 23 in which Jesus is forgiving the sins of the paralyzed man. Jesus says to him, "Man, your sins have been forgiven you." Here the perfect tense is used as a present tense, since the man's since were not forgiven previous to his meeting with Jesus.

Another instance of ‘apheoontai’ is Luke 7:47 in which Jesus is forgiving the sins of the adulterous woman. Her sins were not forgiven prior to her meeting with Jesus, thus Luke is using the perfect tense as a present tense. This is confirmed by Jesus' use of the present tense ‘aphietai’ ("is forgiven") in the same verse; the switch to the perfect tense in verse 48 ("Your sins have been forgiven"); and the other people's recognition of a present forgiveness by the use the present tense ‘aphieesin’ ("forgives").

In light of this, one cannot make the conclusion that the perfect tense in John 20:23 can only mean, as McCarthy claims, that "...the disciples had the authority to declare forgiveness to those whom God had already forgiven."

Quite the opposite is true. Since, as noted above, it would be contradictory for the apostles to be told to forgive sins if the sins have already been forgiven by God, the perfect tense of John 20:23 is used only to intensify the result of the action of the apostles to forgive, which is one of its normal uses in Greek.

It would be the same in English if you gave a command to someone and the person who received the command said, "It has been done, sir," or "Consider it done, sir," before he had actually done the task you gave him. He puts his reply in the perfect tense to show you his determination to get the job done, not necessarily because he had already done the job prior to your asking.

In effect, McCarthy's analysis of the Greek grammar of John 20:23 is a total distortion of what the verse is actually trying to say. The grammar, if looked at properly, says the opposite of what McCarthy is claiming. Luke uses the perfect tense not to negate the apostles' prerogative to forgive sin, but to reinforce that prerogative.

Robert Sungenis
Catholic Apologetics International
December 4, 2000